"So far I have been more enthusiastic about the men's lotion than my husband has. He thinks in general that they are all too strong, and prefers something closer to nature--natural smells. He has tried "Noir", "Ocean", "Twilight Woods" and "Dark Amber". I thought that they were all pretty nice on him, especially "Ocean." He prefers the Aromatherapy item "Warm Milk and Honey." I Still have to try "Paris" and "White Citris" to see if he'll like them. I'm keeping my fingers crossed. 4 stars from me for Dark Amber--2 stars from him."